Pygmy Sunfish is a pretty useful alchemy ingredient, as well as a necessary quest item for Swims-In-Deep-Water’s Caught in the Rain quest. It’s relatively uncommon, and quite a hassle to catch if you don’t know where to look. That’s why in this guide we’ll tell you about some spots where you can fish for it, as well as some where pygmy sunfish spawns as part of the environment, allowing you to catch it with your hands.