True to its Dungeons and Dragons inspiration, Baldur's Gate 3 features many choices that players can make throughout the game. Players can opt to be heroic, helping refugees, saving people in need, and defending the weak. Alternately, many villainous choices are also available - in particular, selecting the Dark Urge origin allows players to embrace murder and violence. Among these less-than-heroic choices, however, there is one which the majority of Baldur's Gate 3 players avoid even on evil playthroughs: returning lovable dog Scratch to the cruel kennel master.