The Acolyte is easily the most controversial Star Wars show so far. It isn't the best entry in the franchise, but it's far from the worst. The series played with new ideas and asked engaging questions, guaranteeing a genuine reaction from some fans. For all of its flaws, this kind of experimentation is always preferable to the boring, risk-averse brand management that Disney usually does with the IP. The show features the live-action debut of a fan-favorite character, but is it a weak appeal to nostalgia or a preview of what's to come?