Vast universes with dense lore such as Stardew Valley are always filled to the brim with mysteries. In Pelican Town, there is some suspicion that Abigail's father might not be Pierre, but rather the Wizard, based on some comments that her mother Caroline makes. Other mysteries ponder the identities of the elusive M. Jasper and Mona while others theorize if Mr. Qi is a stand-in or representative of the developer ConcernedApe himself.